Free Mathematics Class 8 ICSE notes · practise this chapter with an AI quiz

← All study notes

An Emptying Pipe Is the Only One You Ever Subtract

Learn to recognise inverse variation by a constant product, solve speed-time and workers-days problems, combine rates for people working together, and handle filling and emptying pipes.

Why do you add two filling pipes but subtract an emptying one?

Because what you are adding is not time but work done per hour — and an emptying pipe does negative work.

A pipe filling a tank in 66 hours does 16\frac{1}{6} of the job each hour. One filling it in 44 hours does 14\frac{1}{4} each hour. Open both and the tank gains 16+14=512\frac{1}{6} + \frac{1}{4} = \frac{5}{12} of its capacity per hour.

An outlet emptying it in 1212 hours removes 112\frac{1}{12} per hour, so it enters the sum with a minus sign. With all three open the tank gains 16+14−112=13\frac{1}{6} + \frac{1}{4} - \frac{1}{12} = \frac{1}{3} per hour, and fills in 33 hours.

Adding times would have been meaningless. This page covers the second part of the ICSE Class 8 Mathematics chapter on variation.
Formula

What is inverse variation and how do you test for it?

Two quantities are in inverse variation when an increase in one produces a proportionate decrease in the other, so that their product remains constant.

Written y∝1xy \propto \dfrac{1}{x} and read *yy varies inversely as xx*, it means

x×y=kor equivalentlyy=kxx \times y = k \qquad \text{or equivalently} \qquad y = \frac{k}{x}

Compare this with direct variation, where the ratio was constant. Here it is the product, and that single change is the whole difference between the two halves of the chapter.

Worked example 1 — testing a table.

- xx: 44, 66, 88, 1212
- yy: 1818, 1212, 99, 66

Taking each product:

4×18=72,6×12=72,8×9=72,12×6=724 \times 18 = 72, \quad 6 \times 12 = 72, \quad 8 \times 9 = 72, \quad 12 \times 6 = 72

Every product is 7272, so the quantities do vary inversely, with k=72k = 72 and y=72xy = \frac{72}{x}.

Worked example 2 — a table that fails.

- xx: 22, 44, 66
- yy: 1212, 66, 33

2×12=24,4×6=24,6×3=182 \times 12 = 24, \qquad 4 \times 6 = 24, \qquad 6 \times 3 = 18

The last product breaks the pattern, so this is not an inverse variation — even though yy falls as xx rises, and even though the first two pairs agree. Two matching products are not enough; every pair must agree.

Everyday pairs that do vary inversely:

- Speed and time for a fixed distance
- Number of workers and days to finish a fixed job
- Number of people sharing a fixed quantity and the share each gets
- Length and breadth of a rectangle of fixed area

What the constant means. In each case kk is the total that does not change — the distance, the whole job, the quantity to be shared, the area. Naming that total is the quickest way into any problem, and it is what makes the arithmetic obvious.

The boundary case worth stating. The relationship y=kxy = \frac{k}{x} has no value at x=0x = 0, since dividing by zero is undefined. Practically that is exactly right: at zero speed the journey takes no finite time at all, and zero workers never finish the job. Direct variation passes neatly through the origin; inverse variation never reaches either axis.

How do you solve speed-time and workers-days problems?

Find the constant product first — it is the fixed total the question is really about — then divide.

Worked example 1 — speed and time. A car covers a certain distance in 66 hours at 60 km/h60\ \text{km/h}. How long will the same journey take at 80 km/h80\ \text{km/h}?

The constant is the distance:

k=60×6=360 kmk = 60 \times 6 = 360\ \text{km}

time at 80 km/h=36080=4.5 hours\text{time at } 80\ \text{km/h} = \frac{360}{80} = 4.5 \text{ hours}

So 44 hours 3030 minutes. A check on the direction: the speed went up, so the time must come down — and 4.5<64.5 < 6.

Worked example 2 — workers and days. 2424 workers can build a wall in 1515 days. How long will 3030 workers take?

The constant is the total work, measured in worker-days:

k=24×15=360 worker-daysk = 24 \times 15 = 360 \text{ worker-days}

days for 30 workers=36030=12 days\text{days for } 30 \text{ workers} = \frac{360}{30} = 12 \text{ days}

Worked example 3 — the same job, asking for workers. How many workers would finish that wall in 1010 days?

workers=36010=36\text{workers} = \frac{360}{10} = 36

The same constant answers every version of the question, which is why finding kk first is worth the line it takes.

Worked example 4 — by proportion rather than by kk. The inverse-variation proportion is

x1y1=x2y2x_1 y_1 = x_2 y_2

So for the wall with 3030 workers:

24×15=30×y  ⇒  y=36030=1224 \times 15 = 30 \times y \;\Rightarrow\; y = \frac{360}{30} = 12

Notice this is not the direct-variation proportion x1y1=x2y2\frac{x_1}{y_1} = \frac{x_2}{y_2}. For inverse variation the fractions are inverted on one side, so the equation becomes a product — and using the direct form here would have given 2415=30y\frac{24}{15} = \frac{30}{y}, so y=18.75y = 18.75 days, an answer that is larger than 1515 when more workers must clearly take less time.

The check that catches every reversed variation. Before calculating, decide whether the answer should be bigger or smaller than the value given. More workers means fewer days; greater speed means less time; more people sharing means a smaller share. An answer that moves the wrong way has used the wrong variation, and no amount of correct arithmetic afterwards will save it.

How do you solve time-and-work problems?

Convert each person's time into a rate of work per day, add the rates, then invert.

If someone finishes a job in nn days, they complete 1n\dfrac{1}{n} of it each day. That fraction is their rate, and rates are what can be added.

Worked example 1 — two people together. A can do a piece of work in 1212 days and B in 1818 days. How long will they take working together?

A’s rate=112,B’s rate=118\text{A's rate} = \frac{1}{12}, \qquad \text{B's rate} = \frac{1}{18}

together=112+118=336+236=536 of the job per day\text{together} = \frac{1}{12} + \frac{1}{18} = \frac{3}{36} + \frac{2}{36} = \frac{5}{36} \text{ of the job per day}

Inverting the combined rate gives the time:

time=365=7.2 days\text{time} = \frac{36}{5} = 7.2 \text{ days}

So 7157\frac{1}{5} days. A check on the size: working together must take less than the faster person alone, so the answer has to be under 1212 days — and 7.27.2 is.

Why you cannot average the times. Averaging 1212 and 1818 gives 1515 days, which is longer than A takes alone — plainly absurd when B is helping. Times cannot be added or averaged; only rates can.

Worked example 2 — finding one person's time from the pair. A and B together finish a job in 88 days, and A alone takes 1212 days. How long would B alone take?

Subtract A's rate from the combined rate:

B’s rate=18−112=324−224=124\text{B's rate} = \frac{1}{8} - \frac{1}{12} = \frac{3}{24} - \frac{2}{24} = \frac{1}{24}

B alone=24 days\text{B alone} = 24 \text{ days}

Checking: 112+124=224+124=324=18\frac{1}{12} + \frac{1}{24} = \frac{2}{24} + \frac{1}{24} = \frac{3}{24} = \frac{1}{8}, which is 88 days together. Correct.

Worked example 3 — three people. A, B and C can do a job in 1010, 1515 and 3030 days respectively. Working together?

110+115+130=330+230+130=630=15\frac{1}{10} + \frac{1}{15} + \frac{1}{30} = \frac{3}{30} + \frac{2}{30} + \frac{1}{30} = \frac{6}{30} = \frac{1}{5}

time=5 days\text{time} = 5 \text{ days}

Worked example 4 — part of a job. A can finish a job in 1212 days. How much does he complete in 88 days?

8×112=812=23 of the job8 \times \frac{1}{12} = \frac{8}{12} = \frac{2}{3} \text{ of the job}

So one third remains — and that remaining fraction is what the harder versions of these questions hand to a second worker.

The one habit that makes all of these routine. Write down every rate as a fraction before doing anything else. Once the problem is a list of fractions to add or subtract, it is ordinary fraction arithmetic, and the only remaining step is remembering to invert at the end.

How do you solve pipes and cisterns problems?

Exactly like time-and-work, with one addition: a pipe that empties the tank is subtracted.

Worked example 1 — two filling pipes. Pipe A can fill a tank in 66 hours and pipe B in 44 hours. How long will both together take?

16+14=212+312=512 of the tank per hour\frac{1}{6} + \frac{1}{4} = \frac{2}{12} + \frac{3}{12} = \frac{5}{12} \text{ of the tank per hour}

time=125=2.4 hours\text{time} = \frac{12}{5} = 2.4 \text{ hours}

That is 22 hours and 2424 minutes, since 0.40.4 of an hour is 0.4×60=240.4 \times 60 = 24 minutes. Converting the decimal part of an hour into minutes is expected in the answer.

Worked example 2 — with an outlet. Pipe A fills a tank in 66 hours, pipe B fills it in 44 hours, and pipe C empties it in 1212 hours. If all three are opened together, how long will the tank take to fill?

16+14−112=212+312−112=412=13\frac{1}{6} + \frac{1}{4} - \frac{1}{12} = \frac{2}{12} + \frac{3}{12} - \frac{1}{12} = \frac{4}{12} = \frac{1}{3}

time=3 hours\text{time} = 3 \text{ hours}

The outlet has slowed the filling from 2.42.4 hours to 33 hours, which is the direction it must go.

The sign rule, stated plainly. A filling pipe contributes a positive rate and an emptying pipe a negative one. Nothing else about the method changes — and forgetting the minus sign is the single mistake this question type exists to catch.

Worked example 3 — when the outlet wins. Pipe A fills a tank in 88 hours and pipe C empties it in 66 hours. What happens if both are opened?

18−16=324−424=−124\frac{1}{8} - \frac{1}{6} = \frac{3}{24} - \frac{4}{24} = -\frac{1}{24}

The combined rate is negative, so the tank does not fill at all — it empties, at 124\frac{1}{24} per hour. A full tank would take 2424 hours to drain.

A negative answer here is not an error but a meaningful result, and it is worth interpreting in words rather than reporting as a negative time.

Worked example 4 — a tank already part full. Pipes A and B together fill a tank in 2.42.4 hours, as found above. If the tank is already 13\frac{1}{3} full, how long to fill the rest?

The remaining work is 23\frac{2}{3} of a tank at a rate of 512\frac{5}{12} per hour:

time=2/35/12=23×125=2415=1.6 hours\text{time} = \frac{2/3}{5/12} = \frac{2}{3} \times \frac{12}{5} = \frac{24}{15} = 1.6 \text{ hours}

That is 11 hour 3636 minutes. Time equals work divided by rate — and since the full tank at that rate takes 2.42.4 hours, two-thirds of it taking 1.61.6 hours is exactly proportional, as it should be.
Exam tip

Exam tip: add the rates, never the times

In every work or pipe problem, turn each time into a rate — a person finishing in nn days works at 1n\frac{1}{n} per day — then add the rates and invert at the end.

Never add or average the times. Averaging 1212 and 1818 days gives 1515, which is longer than one worker takes alone and is plainly wrong.

An emptying pipe is subtracted. If the combined rate comes out negative, the tank empties rather than fills, and the answer should say so in words.

For inverse variation, use the product x1y1=x2y2x_1 y_1 = x_2 y_2, not the direct-variation ratio. Test a table by checking every product, and one unequal product disproves it.

Predict the direction before calculating: more workers means fewer days, greater speed means less time, more sharers means a smaller share. An answer moving the wrong way means the wrong variation was used.

Name the constant and its unit — 360 km360\ \text{km} of distance, 360360 worker-days of work. The same constant answers every version of the question.

Convert a decimal part of an hour into minutes: 2.42.4 hours is 22 hours 2424 minutes.

And for a partly finished job, use time=work remainingrate\text{time} = \dfrac{\text{work remaining}}{\text{rate}}.
Did you know

Why can nine women not dig a well in one day?

Inverse variation says that if one worker takes nine days, then nine workers take one day — and by the same arithmetic, nine hundred workers would take about fourteen minutes.

The arithmetic is correct and the conclusion is nonsense, which tells you something important about the model rather than about the arithmetic.

Inverse variation assumes every worker is equally productive and that they do not interfere with one another. Both assumptions hold reasonably well for a few workers sharing a large job. Neither survives nine hundred people around one well — most of them cannot reach it, they obstruct each other, and the tools run out long before the space does.

So an examination question saying assuming all workers work at the same rate is not padding. It is the condition that makes the inverse-variation model apply at all, and every such question quietly relies on it.

It is worth knowing where a model stops working. The mathematics of this chapter is exact; what it describes is an idealisation, and the idealisation breaks down long before the formula does.
Key takeaways

Inverse variation, work and pipes: quick revision

- Inverse variation means the product is constant: y∝1xy \propto \frac{1}{x}, so xy=kxy = k or y=kxy = \frac{k}{x}. Compare direct variation, where the ratio is constant.
- Test a table by checking every product. x=4,6,8,12x = 4, 6, 8, 12 with y=18,12,9,6y = 18, 12, 9, 6 all give 7272, so it varies inversely with k=72k = 72. But x=2,4,6x = 2, 4, 6 with y=12,6,3y = 12, 6, 3 gives 2424, 2424, 1818 — not inverse variation.
- Examples: speed and time, workers and days, sharers and share, length and breadth at fixed area. The constant kk is the fixed total.
- y=kxy = \frac{k}{x} has no value at x=0x = 0 — zero speed never completes the journey.
-
Speed and time
: 60×6=360 km60 \times 6 = 360\ \text{km}, so at 80 km/h80\ \text{km/h} the time is 36080=4.5\frac{360}{80} = 4.5 hours.
- Workers and days: 24×15=36024 \times 15 = 360 worker-days, so 3030 workers take 1212 days and 1010 days needs 3636 workers.
- The inverse proportion is x1y1=x2y2x_1 y_1 = x_2 y_2, not x1y1=x2y2\frac{x_1}{y_1} = \frac{x_2}{y_2}.
- Time and work: a job done in nn days means a rate of 1n\frac{1}{n} per day. Add the rates and invert.
- A in 1212 days and B in 1818 gives 112+118=536\frac{1}{12} + \frac{1}{18} = \frac{5}{36}, so together 365=7.2\frac{36}{5} = 7.2 days. Never average the times.
- Together in 88 days with A alone in 1212: B's rate is 18−112=124\frac{1}{8} - \frac{1}{12} = \frac{1}{24}, so B alone takes 2424 days.
- Three workers at 1010, 1515 and 3030 days give 15\frac{1}{5} per day, so 55 days. And A working 88 of his 1212 days completes 23\frac{2}{3}.
- Pipes: filling pipes are added, an emptying pipe is subtracted. A in 66 h and B in 44 h give 512\frac{5}{12}, so 2.42.4 hours — 22 h 2424 min.
- With C emptying in 1212 h: 16+14−112=13\frac{1}{6} + \frac{1}{4} - \frac{1}{12} = \frac{1}{3}, so 33 hours.
- A negative combined rate means the tank empties: 18−16=−124\frac{1}{8} - \frac{1}{6} = -\frac{1}{24}, draining in 2424 hours.
- For a partly filled tank, time=work remainingrate\text{time} = \dfrac{\text{work remaining}}{\text{rate}}: two-thirds at 512\frac{5}{12} per hour takes 1.61.6 hours.

Work a set of pipe problems including one with an outlet that wins — interpreting a negative rate in words is the step that shows you understood the method rather than copied it.

Ready to put this into practice?

Create a personalized quiz on this exact topic — free to start.

Create your own quiz on Direct and Inverse Variations — Part 2Create a free account
← Back to all articles