Free Science Class 9 CBSE notes · practise this chapter with an AI quiz

← All study notes

Twenty Grams of Salt in a Hundred of Water Is Not a Twenty Percent Solution

Learn to classify mixtures as homogeneous or heterogeneous, identify solute and solvent in every state, calculate concentration by mass and by volume, and read a solubility curve.

Why is 20 g of salt in 100 g of water not a 20 percent solution?

Because the percentage is taken over the whole solution, not over the water.

Adding 2020 g of salt to 100100 g of water gives a solution weighing 120120 g, so

mass by mass %=20120×100=16.67%\text{mass by mass \%} = \frac{20}{120} \times 100 = 16.67\%

A genuine 20%20\% solution would need 2020 g of salt in a total of 100100 g — so 2020 g of salt and only 8080 g of water.

The difference looks small and it is the most penalised mistake in the whole chapter, because the formula's denominator is the mass of the solution:

mass of solution=mass of solute+mass of solvent\text{mass of solution} = \text{mass of solute} + \text{mass of solvent}

Read the question carefully enough to know whether you were given the solvent or the solution, and the arithmetic is easy. This page covers the first part of the CBSE Class 9 Science chapter on mixtures and their separation.

How do you tell a homogeneous mixture from a heterogeneous one?

A homogeneous mixture has the same composition throughout; a heterogeneous one does not.

In a homogeneous mixture the components cannot be told apart, and any sample taken from any part has the same composition as any other.

- Salt dissolved in water
- Sugar dissolved in water
- Air
- Alloys such as brass
- Vinegar

In a heterogeneous mixture the components are distinguishable and the composition varies from place to place.

- Sand and water
- Oil and water
- Soil
- A mixture of iron filings and sulphur powder
- Muddy water

Everyday evidence. A cup of sugared tea tastes the same from the top as from the bottom — homogeneous. A plate of poha with peanuts scattered through it gives a different mouthful each time — heterogeneous. Leave muddy water standing and the mud settles at the bottom, which no homogeneous mixture ever does.

The distinction depends on the scale you look at. Milk appears perfectly uniform to the eye, and yet it is heterogeneous — it contains tiny droplets of fat suspended in water. Shine a narrow beam of light through it and the beam becomes visible, scattered by those droplets. A true solution such as salt water does not scatter light this way, and the beam passes through unseen.

That scattering is the Tyndall effect, and it is the test that separates a colloid such as milk from a true solution. A mixture can therefore look homogeneous and still be classified as heterogeneous, which is why looks uniform is not by itself a sufficient answer.

A mixture is not a compound. In a mixture the components keep their own properties and can be separated by physical means, and there is no fixed ratio. In a compound the elements are chemically combined in a fixed ratio and the properties are entirely new — which is why iron filings in sulphur can be separated with a magnet, while iron sulphide cannot.

What are the solute and solvent, and can a solution be a solid?

The solvent is the component present in the greater amount; the solute is what dissolves in it. And yes — solutions exist in all three states.

A solution is a homogeneous mixture of two or more substances, and it has two parts:

- Solute — the substance that dissolves, present in the lesser amount
- Solvent — the substance that does the dissolving, present in the greater amount

Solutions in every state.

- Solid in liquid: salt in water. Solute salt, solvent water.
- Liquid in liquid: alcohol in water.
- Gas in liquid: carbon dioxide in water, which is soda; and oxygen dissolved in river water, which is what fish breathe.
- Solid in solid: alloys. Brass is zinc dissolved in copper — solvent copper, solute zinc.
- Gas in gas: air, with nitrogen as the solvent and oxygen and the other gases as solutes.
- Solid in gas: iodine vapour in air.

Everyday evidence. A brass tumbler is a solid solution — you cannot see the zinc separately anywhere in it. A bottle of soda fizzes when opened because dissolved carbon dioxide escapes once the pressure drops.

Which one is the solvent can change. Mix 3030 g of alcohol with 7070 g of water and the water is the solvent. Reverse the amounts — 7070 g of alcohol and 3030 g of water — and now alcohol is the solvent. The labels describe the proportions, not the substances themselves.

Water is called the universal solvent because it dissolves a very large number of substances, but the name is a description of its range rather than a claim that it dissolves everything. Oil, wax and sand do not dissolve in water at all.

The properties of a true solution, worth knowing as a set:

- The particles are so small they cannot be seen even with a microscope
- The solute particles do not settle on standing
- The solution is stable and does not separate
- It cannot be filtered — the solute passes through filter paper with the solvent
- It does not scatter a beam of light

That last property is what distinguished salt water from milk in the previous section, and the fourth explains why filtration is useless for separating a solution — which is the whole reason the second part of this chapter needs different techniques.
Formula

How do you calculate the concentration of a solution?

Two formulas, and the denominator of each is the solution, never the solvent:

mass by mass %=mass of solutemass of solution×100\text{mass by mass \%} = \frac{\text{mass of solute}}{\text{mass of solution}} \times 100

mass by volume %=mass of solutevolume of solution×100\text{mass by volume \%} = \frac{\text{mass of solute}}{\text{volume of solution}} \times 100

with

mass of solution=mass of solute+mass of solvent\text{mass of solution} = \text{mass of solute} + \text{mass of solvent}

Worked example 1 — solvent mass given. 2020 g of salt is dissolved in 8080 g of water.

mass of solution=20+80=100 g\text{mass of solution} = 20 + 80 = 100 \text{ g}

mass by mass %=20100×100=20%\text{mass by mass \%} = \frac{20}{100} \times 100 = 20\%

Worked example 2. 55 g of sugar is dissolved in 4545 g of water.

mass of solution=50 g,550×100=10%\text{mass of solution} = 50 \text{ g}, \qquad \frac{5}{50} \times 100 = 10\%

Worked example 3 — solution mass given. A solution of total mass 5050 g contains 2.52.5 g of solute.

2.550×100=5%\frac{2.5}{50} \times 100 = 5\%

and the solvent mass is 50−2.5=47.550 - 2.5 = 47.5 g.

Worked example 4 — the trap, worked in full. 2020 g of salt is dissolved in 100100 g of water.

The solution now weighs 120120 g, so

20120×100=16.67%\frac{20}{120} \times 100 = 16.67\%

not 20%20\%. Compare with worked example 1, where 100100 g was the mass of the solution. The two questions differ by one word and by nearly four percentage points.

Worked example 5 — mass by volume. 88 g of a substance is dissolved to give 200200 mL of solution.

8200×100=4%\frac{8}{200} \times 100 = 4\%

Worked example 6 — working backwards. How much solute is present in 250250 g of a 12%12\% solution?

solute=12100×250=30 g\text{solute} = \frac{12}{100} \times 250 = 30 \text{ g}

so the solvent is 250−30=220250 - 30 = 220 g.

Worked example 7 — preparing a solution. To make 500500 g of a 4%4\% solution:

solute=4100×500=20 g,water=500−20=480 g\text{solute} = \frac{4}{100} \times 500 = 20 \text{ g}, \qquad \text{water} = 500 - 20 = 480 \text{ g}

So you weigh out 2020 g of solute and add 480480 g of water — not 500500 g of water, which would give a solution of 520520 g and a concentration of 3.85%3.85\%.

State which percentage you have used. *A 10%10\% solution is ambiguous on its own; 10%10\% by mass or 10%10\% by mass by volume* is complete. The two are not equal unless the solution's density happens to be 11 g per mL.

How does temperature change solubility, and what does a curve show?

For most solids, solubility rises with temperature. For gases, it falls.

Solubility is the maximum mass of solute that dissolves in 100100 g of solvent at a stated temperature. The temperature has to be stated, because solubility is not a single fixed number for a substance.

- A
saturated solution holds as much solute as it can at that temperature, and no more will dissolve
- An
unsaturated solution can still dissolve more

Worked example 1 — scaling up from a solubility figure.
The solubility of potassium nitrate is 3232 g per 100100 g of water at 20 ∘C20\ ^\circ\text{C}. How much dissolves in 250250 g of water at that temperature?

32×250100=32×2.5=80 g32 \times \frac{250}{100} = 32 \times 2.5 = 80 \text{ g}

Worked example 2 — reading a curve and cooling a solution. A solubility curve shows a salt dissolving to the extent of 6060 g per 100100 g of water at 60 ∘C60\ ^\circ\text{C}, and 4040 g per 100100 g at 30 ∘C30\ ^\circ\text{C}.

A saturated solution made at 60 ∘C60\ ^\circ\text{C} holds 6060 g. Cool it to 30 ∘C30\ ^\circ\text{C} and the water can now hold only 4040 g, so

mass that crystallises out=60−40=20 g\text{mass that crystallises out} = 60 - 40 = 20 \text{ g}

That surplus appears as solid crystals, and it is exactly the process the next part of this chapter uses to purify a substance.

Worked example 3 — is it saturated? 5050 g of a salt is added to 200200 g of water at 40 ∘C40\ ^\circ\text{C}, where its solubility is 3636 g per 100100 g.

maximum that can dissolve=36×2=72 g\text{maximum that can dissolve} = 36 \times 2 = 72 \text{ g}

Since 50<7250 < 72, all of it dissolves and the solution is unsaturated. Adding a further 2222 g would just saturate it.

Gases behave the opposite way. The solubility of a gas in a liquid falls as temperature rises, and rises as pressure rises.

Everyday evidence for both. Sugar dissolves far more readily in hot tea than in cold water — solid solubility rising with temperature. A fizzy drink left in the sun goes flat much faster than one in the fridge, because warming drives the dissolved carbon dioxide out — gas solubility falling with temperature. And the drink fizzes on opening because releasing the pressure lowers the solubility further.

Why this matters beyond the laboratory. Because warm water holds less dissolved oxygen, fish are harder pressed in a heated pond than a cool one — the same physical rule, with a biological consequence.

Solubility is a property of a pair, not of a substance. It always describes a particular solute in a particular solvent at a particular temperature. Sugar is highly soluble in water and barely soluble in oil — so sugar is soluble is an incomplete statement, and a question that omits the temperature cannot be answered with a number.
Exam tip

Exam tip: divide by the solution, never by the solvent

Mass of solution == mass of solute ++ mass of solvent. Put the solution in the denominator every time.

Read whether the question gave you the mass of
water or of the solution
. 2020 g salt in 8080 g water is 20%20\%; 2020 g salt in 100100 g water is 16.67%16.67\%.

To prepare a solution, subtract: 500500 g of a 4%4\% solution needs 2020 g solute and 480480 g water.

Say which percentage you mean — by mass, or by mass by volume.

Solubility is the maximum solute per 100100 g of solvent at a stated temperature
. Scale it: 3232 g per 100100 g means 8080 g in 250250 g of water.

For a cooling question, subtract the two solubilities: 60−40=2060 - 40 = 20 g crystallises out.

Solid solubility rises with temperature; gas solubility falls with temperature and rises with pressure.

Homogeneous means uniform throughout with indistinguishable components; heterogeneous does not. Milk looks uniform but is heterogeneous — it shows the Tyndall effect.

The solvent is whichever is present in the greater amount, so it can change when the proportions change.

Remember that a true solution cannot be filtered and does not settle — which rules filtration out for separating one.

And write units on every mass and the %\% sign on every concentration.
Did you know

Why a warm fizzy drink goes flat so quickly

Open a chilled bottle of soda and it hisses gently. Open a warm one and it foams over the top. The same drink, and two quite different results.
Both come from the same rule: a gas dissolves less in a liquid as the temperature rises, and more as the pressure rises. A soda bottle is filled with carbon dioxide under pressure and then sealed, which is what keeps the gas dissolved.

Opening the bottle removes the pressure, so the solubility drops at once and the surplus gas leaves solution as bubbles. In a cold bottle the solubility was high to begin with, so less gas is surplus and the escape is slow. In a warm bottle the solubility was already low, a great deal of gas is surplus, and it all tries to leave at the same moment.

This is also why the drink tastes flat after standing. The dissolved gas is not merely a source of bubbles; carbon dioxide in water makes the drink slightly acidic, and losing it changes the taste as well as the fizz.

The same rule explains something with much larger consequences. River and pond water hold dissolved oxygen, and fish depend on it. Warm the water and it holds less oxygen — so a pond in a hot spell or a river receiving warm water from a factory can starve its fish of oxygen without any pollutant being added at all.

And it runs the other way too. Water boiled and cooled tastes noticeably flat because boiling drove the dissolved air out of it, which is why laboratory water for some experiments is deliberately boiled first.

So gas solubility falls with temperature is not an isolated fact to memorise beside the opposite rule for solids. It is one rule, and it turns up wherever a gas is dissolved in a liquid — which is to say, in every drink, every river and every fish tank.
Exam relevance

Why does concentration keep reappearing in JEE and NEET Chemistry?

Because every quantitative statement in chemistry is a statement about how much of what, in how much of something else — and this page is where that idea is first put into a formula.

This is the foundation for the Class 11 Chemistry chapter Some Basic Concepts of Chemistry, examined in both JEE Main and NEET. That chapter introduces molarity, molality and mole fraction, and every one of them follows the same pattern as the percentage formulas here: an amount of solute divided by a fixed amount of solution or solvent. The Class 9 distinction between dividing by the solution and dividing by the solvent becomes the formal distinction between molarity (moles per litre of solution) and molality (moles per kilogram of solvent) — and students who never settled it here get the two confused there.

Solubility and temperature feed into the Class 12 chapter Solutions, a substantial part of both JEE Main and NEET Chemistry. There the qualitative rule on this page becomes Henry's law for gas solubility, with pressure and temperature handled quantitatively, and the same fizzy-drink reasoning is used as the standard illustration.

Homogeneous against heterogeneous reappears in Class 11 when States of Matter and later Equilibrium distinguish homogeneous from heterogeneous equilibria, and in Class 12 Surface Chemistry, where colloids and the Tyndall effect are treated in full.

Alloys as solid solutions return in Class 12 The p-Block Elements and Metallurgy.

What the questions look like. Numericals on concentration are common, and the trap is nearly always the denominator. Assertion-reason items favour gas solubility falling with temperature, and the Tyndall effect distinguishing a colloid from a true solution. Graph-reading questions give a solubility curve and ask how much crystallises on cooling — precisely the 60−40=2060 - 40 = 20 g calculation worked above. Match-the-column items pair a solution type with an example, where brass and air are the two that catch students out.

How board and competitive emphasis differ. A board paper asks you to define solubility or to give two differences between a solution and a colloid, then sets a one-step percentage sum. A competitive paper sets the same sum with the solvent mass given rather than the solution mass, or asks for the mass of water needed to prepare a stated solution — so the reasoning about the denominator, rather than the formula itself, is what is being tested.

The single trap that costs the most marks. Dividing by the mass of the solvent instead of the solution. Write the line mass of solution=solute+solvent\text{mass of solution} = \text{solute} + \text{solvent} before every calculation, and the error becomes impossible.

A second trap worth naming. Quoting a solubility without its temperature, or treating solubility as a fixed property of a substance. It is a property of a solute-solvent pair at a stated temperature, and a question that gives a temperature is giving it because the answer depends on it.
Key takeaways

Mixtures, solutions and concentration: quick revision

- Homogeneous mixtures are uniform throughout with indistinguishable components: salt water, sugar solution, air, brass, vinegar.
- Heterogeneous mixtures vary from place to place: sand and water, oil and water, soil, iron filings with sulphur, muddy water.
- Milk looks uniform but is heterogeneous — it scatters a light beam, the Tyndall effect, which a true solution does not.
- A mixture keeps its components' properties, has no fixed ratio, and can be separated physically; a compound cannot.
- Solvent is the component in the greater amount; solute the lesser. Swap the amounts and the labels swap too.
- Solutions exist in all states: salt in water, alcohol in water, carbon dioxide in water, brass (zinc in copper), air (gases in gas), iodine vapour in air.
- A true solution has invisible particles, does not settle, is stable, cannot be filtered, and does not scatter light.
- Mass of solution == solute ++ solvent, and this is the denominator in both formulas.
- mass by mass %=solutesolution×100\text{mass by mass \%} = \frac{\text{solute}}{\text{solution}} \times 100; mass by volume %=solutevolume of solution×100\text{mass by volume \%} = \frac{\text{solute}}{\text{volume of solution}} \times 100.
- 2020 g salt in 8080 g water gives 20%20\%; 2020 g salt in 100100 g water gives 16.67%16.67\%. One word apart.
- 55 g sugar in 4545 g water is 10%10\%; 2.52.5 g in a 5050 g solution is 5%5\%; 88 g in 200200 mL is 4%4\% by mass by volume.
- Backwards: 250250 g of a 12%12\% solution holds 3030 g solute and 220220 g water. To make 500500 g of a 4%4\% solution, take 2020 g solute and 480480 g water.
-
Solubility is the maximum solute per 100100 g of solvent at a stated temperature. A saturated
solution can hold no more.
- 3232 g per 100100 g at 20 ∘C20\ ^\circ\text{C} means 8080 g dissolves in 250250 g of water.
- Cooling a saturated solution from 60 ∘C60\ ^\circ\text{C} (6060 g per 100100 g) to 30 ∘C30\ ^\circ\text{C} (4040 g per 100100 g) crystallises out 2020 g.
- 5050 g added to 200200 g of water where solubility is 3636 g per 100100 g stays unsaturated, since the maximum is 7272 g.
- Solid solubility rises with temperature; gas solubility falls with temperature and rises with pressure — hence flat warm soda and less oxygen in warm water.
- Solubility describes a pair at a temperature, not a substance on its own.

Work one concentration sum where the water mass is given and one where the solution mass is given, side by side — seeing the two answers differ is the fastest way to make the denominator stick.

Ready to put this into practice?

Create a personalized quiz on this exact topic — free to start.

Create your own quiz on Exploring Mixtures and their Separation — Part 1Create a free account
← Back to all articles