Free Mathematics Class 8 ICSE notes · practise this chapter with an AI quiz

← All study notes

Two Quantities Rising Together Is Not Enough to Be Proportional

Learn what direct variation really requires, find the constant of proportionality from any pair of values, solve problems by the unitary method and by proportion, and test a table of values properly.

Do two quantities that increase together always vary directly?

No — and this is the point the whole chapter turns on.

A taxi fare rises as the distance rises, but it is not in direct variation with distance, because there is usually a fixed charge before the meter starts. Double the distance and the fare does not double, since the fixed part was not doubled.

Direct variation demands something much stricter than rising together: the ratio of the two quantities must stay exactly the same. Doubling one must double the other, and halving one must halve the other.

So the test is arithmetical, not visual. This page covers the first part of the ICSE Class 8 Mathematics chapter on variation.
Formula

What is direct variation and how do you find the constant?

Two quantities are in direct variation if an increase in one produces a proportionate increase in the other, so that their ratio remains constant.

Written y∝xy \propto x and read *yy varies directly as xx*, it means

yx=kor equivalentlyy=kx\frac{y}{x} = k \qquad \text{or equivalently} \qquad y = kx

where kk is the constant of proportionality, also called the constant of variation.

Finding kk needs only one pair of values. Divide the second quantity by the first, and the answer holds for every other pair.

Worked example 1.
If 1212 pens cost ₹96\text{₹}96, find the constant of proportionality and the cost of 2020 pens.

k=9612=₹8 per penk = \frac{96}{12} = \text{₹}8 \text{ per pen}

cost of 20 pens=20×8=₹160\text{cost of } 20 \text{ pens} = 20 \times 8 = \text{₹}160

Notice what kk means here — it is the cost of one pen, and it carries the unit rupees per pen. In every direct variation the constant is a rate, which is why identifying it makes the problem concrete.

Worked example 2. A car travels 240 km240\ \text{km} on 16 L16\ \text{L} of fuel. How far will it travel on 25 L25\ \text{L}?

k=24016=15 km per litrek = \frac{240}{16} = 15\ \text{km per litre}

distance=25×15=375 km\text{distance} = 25 \times 15 = 375\ \text{km}

Everyday pairs that do vary directly:

- Cost and the number of articles bought, at a fixed rate
- Distance and time, at a constant speed
- Weight and the number of identical objects
- The circumference of a circle and its diameter, with k=πk = \pi

The graph test. Plotting yy against xx for a direct variation gives a straight line through the origin. The line must pass through (0,0)(0,0), because y=kxy = kx forces y=0y = 0 when x=0x = 0 — no articles cost nothing.

Which is exactly why the taxi fare fails. Its graph is a straight line, but it cuts the vertical axis above the origin at the fixed charge. A relationship of the form y=kx+cy = kx + c with c≠0c \neq 0 is not a direct variation, however straight its graph is, and this is the single commonest misconception in the chapter.

How do you solve a direct variation problem?

Two standard methods, and both give the same answer.

The unitary method — find the value for one unit, then multiply.

Worked example 1. If 15 m15\ \text{m} of cloth costs ₹1125\text{₹}1125, find the cost of 8 m8\ \text{m}.

cost of 1 m=112515=₹75\text{cost of } 1\ \text{m} = \frac{1125}{15} = \text{₹}75

cost of 8 m=8×75=₹600\text{cost of } 8\ \text{m} = 8 \times 75 = \text{₹}600

The proportion method — set the two ratios equal and cross-multiply.

x1y1=x2y2\frac{x_1}{y_1} = \frac{x_2}{y_2}

151125=8y  ⇒  y=8×112515=₹600\frac{15}{1125} = \frac{8}{y} \;\Rightarrow\; y = \frac{8 \times 1125}{15} = \text{₹}600

The same ₹600\text{₹}600, and the proportion method avoids the intermediate division when it does not come out neatly.

Worked example 2 — working the other way. If 15 m15\ \text{m} of cloth costs ₹1125\text{₹}1125, how much cloth can be bought for ₹1500\text{₹}1500?

151125=x1500  ⇒  x=15×15001125=20 m\frac{15}{1125} = \frac{x}{1500} \;\Rightarrow\; x = \frac{15 \times 1500}{1125} = 20\ \text{m}

Or by the unitary method: ₹75\text{₹}75 buys one metre, so ₹1500\text{₹}1500 buys 150075=20 m\frac{1500}{75} = 20\ \text{m}.

Worked example 3 — a three-step problem. If 99 workers earn ₹13500\text{₹}13500 in a week, what will 1414 workers earn in the same week?

k=135009=₹1500 per workerk = \frac{13500}{9} = \text{₹}1500 \text{ per worker}

14×1500=₹2100014 \times 1500 = \text{₹}21000

How to set a proportion up safely. Keep like quantities in like positions — both cloth lengths on top and both costs underneath, or both on the same side of each fraction. Mixing a length with a cost across the fraction bar gives an equation that is dimensionally meaningless and an answer that is wrong.

The check that catches a reversed proportion. Ask whether the answer should be bigger or smaller than the given value before calculating. Eight metres is less than fifteen, so the cost must be less than ₹1125\text{₹}1125 — and ₹600\text{₹}600 is. Had the fractions been inverted the answer would have come to ₹2109\text{₹}2109, which fails that test immediately.

How do you test whether a table of values varies directly?

Divide each yy by its xx and check that every ratio is the same. One ratio out of line is enough to disprove it.

Worked example 1 — a table that does vary directly.


- xx: 22, 55, 88, 1212
- yy: 1414, 3535, 5656, 8484

Taking each ratio:

142=7,355=7,568=7,8412=7\frac{14}{2} = 7, \qquad \frac{35}{5} = 7, \qquad \frac{56}{8} = 7, \qquad \frac{84}{12} = 7

Every ratio is 77, so the quantities do vary directly, with k=7k = 7 and y=7xy = 7x.

Worked example 2 — a table that does not.

- xx: 22, 44, 66
- yy: 55, 99, 1313

52=2.5,94=2.25,136≈2.17\frac{5}{2} = 2.5, \qquad \frac{9}{4} = 2.25, \qquad \frac{13}{6} \approx 2.17

The ratios are not equal, so this is not a direct variation — even though yy increases steadily as xx does, and even though the differences are perfectly regular.

Look closely at why it failed. The yy values rise by 44 each time the xx values rise by 22, so the relationship is y=2x+1y = 2x + 1. That is a straight line, but its constant term +1+1 means it misses the origin, and the ratio yx\frac{y}{x} therefore drifts. Regular differences are not the same as a constant ratio, and this pair of examples is the clearest way to see it.

Completing a table once kk is known. With k=7k = 7 from the first example:

- If x=20x = 20, then y=7×20=140y = 7 \times 20 = 140
- If y=63y = 63, then x=637=9x = \frac{63}{7} = 9
- If x=1.5x = 1.5, then y=10.5y = 10.5

Once the constant is found, every missing entry is a single multiplication or division — which is why finding kk first is always the right opening move.

A faster test for a longer table. Instead of computing every ratio, check whether yx\frac{y}{x} is the same for the first and last rows, then spot-check one in the middle. If the relationship really is y=kxy = kx, any two rows will agree; if it is y=kx+cy = kx + c, the first and last will disagree most.

And a warning about rounding. Real measured data rarely gives ratios that agree exactly. A question with tidy whole numbers expects exact agreement, and a ratio that is nearly equal — like 2.52.5 and 2.252.25 above — means not a direct variation, not an approximate one.
Exam tip

Exam tip: check the ratio, not the direction

To prove direct variation you must show the ratio yx\frac{y}{x} is constant. Saying *yy increases as xx increases* proves nothing — y=2x+1y = 2x + 1 does that and is not a direct variation.

Compute every ratio in a table and state that they are equal, giving the value of kk. To disprove it, one unequal ratio is enough, and you should point to it.

Always find and name the constant with its unit — ₹8\text{₹}8 per pen, 15 km15\ \text{km} per litre. It makes the rest of the problem concrete and it is usually worth a mark.

In a proportion, keep like quantities in like positions. Both lengths on top and both costs underneath.

Predict the direction first. If the new quantity is smaller, the answer must be smaller. That single check catches an inverted proportion instantly.

Remember the graph of a direct variation is a straight line through the origin. A line cutting the axis above the origin is y=kx+cy = kx + c and is not direct variation.

Use the unitary method when the division comes out neatly and proportion when it does not.

And note that equal differences are not the same as a constant ratio — the rows rising by a fixed step is exactly the trap.
Did you know

Why must a proportional graph pass through the origin?

It is easy to treat goes through the origin as an extra rule bolted onto direct variation. It is not a rule at all — it is unavoidable.

Direct variation says y=kxy = kx. Put x=0x = 0 into that and you get y=k×0=0y = k \times 0 = 0, whatever the value of kk. So the point (0,0)(0, 0) satisfies every direct variation there has ever been, and the line has no choice but to pass through it.

In words: no articles cost nothing, no time covers no distance, no petrol takes you nowhere. Every genuine direct variation makes that statement true, and if a situation makes it false, the situation is not a direct variation.

That is why the taxi fare, the electricity bill with a fixed charge, and the mobile plan with a monthly rental all fail the test. Each one charges something for zero usage, so each one has a line that starts above the origin — and for each one, doubling the usage fails to double the bill. The origin is not a detail of the graph; it is the whole definition, drawn.
Key takeaways

Direct variation: quick revision

- Two quantities are in direct variation when their ratio is constant: y∝xy \propto x means yx=k\dfrac{y}{x} = k, or y=kxy = kx.
- kk is the constant of proportionality, found from one pair of values, and it is always a rate with a unit.
- 1212 pens for ₹96\text{₹}96 gives k=₹8k = \text{₹}8 per pen, so 2020 pens cost ₹160\text{₹}160. A car doing 240 km240\ \text{km} on 16 L16\ \text{L} gives k=15 km/Lk = 15\ \text{km/L}, so 25 L25\ \text{L} takes it 375 km375\ \text{km}.
- Examples: cost and quantity, distance and time at constant speed, weight and number of identical objects, circumference and diameter with k=πk = \pi.
- The graph is a straight line through the origin, because y=kxy = kx forces y=0y = 0 at x=0x = 0.
- A relationship y=kx+cy = kx + c with c≠0c \neq 0 — a taxi fare with a fixed charge — is not direct variation, however straight its graph.
- Unitary method: 15 m15\ \text{m} for ₹1125\text{₹}1125 gives ₹75\text{₹}75 per metre, so 8 m8\ \text{m} costs ₹600\text{₹}600.
- Proportion: 151125=8y\dfrac{15}{1125} = \dfrac{8}{y} gives y=₹600y = \text{₹}600; and ₹1500\text{₹}1500 buys 20 m20\ \text{m}.
- 99 workers earning ₹13500\text{₹}13500 means ₹1500\text{₹}1500 each, so 1414 workers earn ₹21000\text{₹}21000.
- Keep like quantities in like positions, and predict whether the answer should be bigger or smaller before calculating.
- Testing a table: x=2,5,8,12x = 2, 5, 8, 12 with y=14,35,56,84y = 14, 35, 56, 84 gives every ratio 77, so it varies directly with y=7xy = 7x.
- x=2,4,6x = 2, 4, 6 with y=5,9,13y = 5, 9, 13 gives ratios 2.52.5, 2.252.25 and about 2.172.17 — not direct variation, since the relationship is y=2x+1y = 2x + 1.
- Equal differences are not a constant ratio. Once kk is known, any missing entry is one multiplication or division: with k=7k = 7, x=20x = 20 gives y=140y = 140 and y=63y = 63 gives x=9x = 9.

Test a few tables of your own and, for each one that fails, work out the y=kx+cy = kx + c it actually follows — seeing where the constant term comes from is what makes the definition stick.

Ready to put this into practice?

Create a personalized quiz on this exact topic — free to start.

Create your own quiz on Direct and Inverse Variations — Part 1Create a free account
← Back to all articles