Free Physics Class 11 CBSE notes · practise this chapter with an AI quiz

← All study notes

No Engine Can Ever Turn All Its Heat Into Work

State the second law of thermodynamics in Kelvin-Planck and Clausius forms, tell reversible from irreversible processes, trace the four steps of the Carnot cycle on a P-V diagram, and derive why Carnot efficiency sets the upper limit.

If energy is always conserved, why can't an engine be perfect?

The first law says energy cannot be created or destroyed. It would allow an engine that turns every joule of heat into work. Yet no such engine exists — every car engine and power station throws away a large share of its heat.

The reason is the second law of thermodynamics, which sets a firm limit on how much work heat can give.

This part covers the two statements of the second law, reversible and irreversible processes, the Carnot cycle, and Carnot efficiency.

What are the Kelvin-Planck and Clausius statements of the second law?

Kelvin-Planck: no process is possible whose sole result is absorbing heat from a reservoir and converting it completely into work. Clausius: no process is possible whose sole result is transferring heat from a colder body to a hotter body.

Heat engine. It absorbs Q1Q_1 from a hot source, does work WW and rejects Q2Q_2 to a cold sink:

W=Q1−Q2η=WQ1=1−Q2Q1W = Q_1 - Q_2 \qquad \eta = \frac{W}{Q_1} = 1 - \frac{Q_2}{Q_1}

Refrigerator. Work WW removes Q2Q_2 from a cold space and releases Q1=Q2+WQ_1 = Q_2 + W; its coefficient of performance is α=Q2W\alpha = \frac{Q_2}{W}.

Worked example 1 — an engine. It absorbs 10001000 J and rejects 600600 J:

W=400 Jη=4001000=0.4=40%W = 400 \text{ J} \qquad \eta = \frac{400}{1000} = 0.4 = 40\%

Worked example 2 — a refrigerator. It removes 300300 J from inside using 100100 J of work: α=3\alpha = 3.

An everyday example. A car's radiator and exhaust get hot — that is the heat Q2Q_2 every engine must reject to its surroundings.

The substance. Kelvin-Planck forbids η=1\eta = 1 and Clausius forbids a refrigerator with W=0W = 0 — neither is ruled out by the first law alone.

What makes a process reversible or irreversible?

A reversible process can be run backwards so that both the system and its surroundings return exactly to their original states; any process involving friction, viscosity, sudden changes or heat flow across a finite temperature difference is irreversible.

Causes of irreversibility:

- Friction and viscous drag, turning work into heat
- Heat flowing from a hot to a cold body across a temperature gap
- Free expansion of a gas into a vacuum
- Mixing of different substances

Worked example — free expansion versus slow expansion. 11 mol of ideal gas at 300300 K doubles its volume.

- Free expansion into vacuum: W=0W = 0, Q=0Q = 0, so ΔU=0\Delta U = 0 — no work is obtained
- Slow, reversible isothermal expansion: W=8.314×300×ln⁡2≈1.73×103W = 8.314 \times 300 \times \ln 2 \approx 1.73 \times 10^3 J

Same start and end states, but the irreversible path wastes the chance to get 1.73×1031.73 \times 10^3 J of work.

An everyday example. A drop of ink spreading through a glass of water never gathers itself back into a drop.

The substance. Every real process is irreversible
; the reversible process is an ideal that gives the most work possible.

What are the four steps of the Carnot cycle, and how does it look on a P-V diagram?

The Carnot cycle is a reversible cycle of four steps — isothermal expansion at the source temperature T1T_1, adiabatic expansion down to T2T_2, isothermal compression at the sink temperature T2T_2, and adiabatic compression back to T1T_1.

-
Step 1 — isothermal expansion
at T1T_1: absorbs heat Q1Q_1 and does work
- Step 2 — adiabatic expansion: temperature falls from T1T_1 to T2T_2 with no heat exchange
- Step 3 — isothermal compression at T2T_2: rejects heat Q2Q_2
- Step 4 — adiabatic compression: temperature rises back to T1T_1

On a P-V diagram, the cycle is a closed loop bounded by two isotherms and two steeper adiabats; the enclosed area is the net work W=Q1−Q2W = Q_1 - Q_2.

Worked example. 11 mol of ideal gas runs between 600600 K and 300300 K, doubling its volume in step 1. Because the two adiabats give equal volume ratios, step 3 halves the volume:

Q1=8.314×600×ln⁡2≈3.46×103 JQ2=8.314×300×ln⁡2≈1.73×103 JQ_1 = 8.314 \times 600 \times \ln 2 \approx 3.46 \times 10^3 \text{ J} \qquad Q_2 = 8.314 \times 300 \times \ln 2 \approx 1.73 \times 10^3 \text{ J}

W≈1.73×103 Jη=1.733.46=50%W \approx 1.73 \times 10^3 \text{ J} \qquad \eta = \frac{1.73}{3.46} = 50\%

An everyday example. A thermal power station takes in heat at a high temperature in its boiler and dumps heat at a low temperature in its cooling towers — the same source-and-sink pattern.

The substance. No real engine runs a true Carnot cycle, but it is the benchmark every engine is compared with.

How do you derive Carnot efficiency, and why is it the upper limit?

For a Carnot engine, Q2Q1=T2T1\frac{Q_2}{Q_1} = \frac{T_2}{T_1}, so its efficiency is η=1−T2T1\eta = 1 - \frac{T_2}{T_1}; Carnot's theorem states that no engine working between the same two temperatures can be more efficient than a reversible one.

Derivation outline.
From the isotherms, Q1=μRT1ln⁡V2V1Q_1 = \mu RT_1\ln\frac{V_2}{V_1} and Q2=μRT2ln⁡V3V4Q_2 = \mu RT_2\ln\frac{V_3}{V_4}. The adiabats, with TVγ−1TV^{\gamma - 1} constant, give V3V4=V2V1\frac{V_3}{V_4} = \frac{V_2}{V_1}, so

Q2Q1=T2T1⇒η=1−T2T1\frac{Q_2}{Q_1} = \frac{T_2}{T_1} \Rightarrow \eta = 1 - \frac{T_2}{T_1}

Worked example 1. Steam at 800800 K with a sink at 300300 K:

ηmax=1−300800=0.625=62.5%\eta_{max} = 1 - \frac{300}{800} = 0.625 = 62.5\%

Worked example 2 — which change helps more?

- Lower the sink to 250250 K: η=1−250800≈68.8%\eta = 1 - \frac{250}{800} \approx 68.8\%
- Raise the source to 900900 K: η=1−300900≈66.7%\eta = 1 - \frac{300}{900} \approx 66.7\%

Why it is the limit. If some engine beat a Carnot engine, it could drive the Carnot engine backwards as a refrigerator and together they would move heat from cold to hot with no work — breaking the Clausius statement.

An everyday example. Cooling towers at a power plant keep the sink as cold as possible, because a lower T2T_2 raises the possible efficiency.

The substance. Efficiency could reach 100%100\% only with a sink at 00 K, which cannot be reached — and it does not depend on the working gas.
Exam tip

What earns full marks on the second law and Carnot engines?

Convert every temperature to kelvin before using 1−T2T11 - \frac{T_2}{T_1}.

-
Kelvin-Planck: no complete conversion of heat to work
-
Clausius: no heat flow from cold to hot without work
-
Engine
: η=WQ1=1−Q2Q1\eta = \frac{W}{Q_1} = 1 - \frac{Q_2}{Q_1}
- Carnot: η=1−T2T1\eta = 1 - \frac{T_2}{T_1}; refrigerator α=T2T1−T2\alpha = \frac{T_2}{T_1 - T_2}
- Cycle order: isothermal, adiabatic, isothermal, adiabatic

The trap. Using Celsius. Between 527527 °C and 2727 °C the efficiency is 1−300800=62.5%1 - \frac{300}{800} = 62.5\%, not 1−275271 - \frac{27}{527}.
Did you know

Why does an air conditioner struggle most on the hottest days?

An ideal refrigerator or air conditioner has a coefficient of performance α=T2T1−T2\alpha = \frac{T_2}{T_1 - T_2}, where T2T_2 is the cool room and T1T_1 the outdoor air.

Keeping a room at 300300 K:

- Outside at 310310 K: α=30010=30\alpha = \frac{300}{10} = 30
- Outside at 320320 K: α=30020=15\alpha = \frac{300}{20} = 15

Just 1010 K of extra outdoor heat halves the ideal performance, so each joule of electricity removes only half as much heat.
Exam relevance

How are the second law and Carnot engines tested in JEE Main and NEET?

The second law, heat engines and refrigerators close the Thermodynamics chapter in both JEE Main and NEET, and JEE Advanced combines Carnot efficiency with multi-step cycles and entropy ideas.

What gets asked. Carnot efficiency when source or sink temperature changes, finding the temperatures from two efficiency conditions, coefficient of performance of refrigerators, work from heat absorbed and rejected, and statements on reversible and irreversible processes. NEET frequently asks statement-based questions on the two forms of the second law.

Question types. Numericals, ratio problems and assertion-reason statements.

The trap that costs marks. Plugging Celsius temperatures into 1−T2T11 - \frac{T_2}{T_1}, which gives impossible efficiencies.
Key takeaways

What must you be able to do from this part?

- Second law: Kelvin-Planck and Clausius forms; engine absorbing 10001000 J and rejecting 600600 J has η=40%\eta = 40\%
- Reversibility: quasi-static, no friction; free expansion wastes 1.73×1031.73 \times 10^3 J of possible work
- Carnot cycle: isothermal, adiabatic, isothermal, adiabatic; 600600 K to 300300 K gives 50%50\%
- Carnot efficiency: 1−T2T11 - \frac{T_2}{T_1}; 62.5%62.5\% between 800800 K and 300300 K; lowering the sink helps more

A Carnot engine has efficiency 40%40\% with its sink at 300300 K. By how much must the source temperature rise for the efficiency to become 50%50\%?

Ready to put this into practice?

Create a personalized quiz on this exact topic — free to start.

Create your own quiz on Thermodynamics — Part 3Create a free account
← Back to all articles