Free Mathematics Class 10 ICSE notes · practise this chapter with an AI quiz

← All study notes

When a Word Problem Gives Two Answers, How Do You Know Which One Is Real?

Turn word problems on numbers, ages, two-digit numbers, trains and boats, fields, paths and pipes into quadratic equations, solve them, and learn how to reject the root that cannot fit the situation.

How do you turn a word problem into a quadratic equation?

Every problem in this chapter follows the same four steps:

- Let the unknown quantity be xx, and write the other quantities in terms of xx
- Form an equation from the condition in the problem
- Solve the quadratic equation
- Check both roots against the situation and reject any that are impossible, giving the reason

A length, speed or age cannot be negative, so one root is often rejected.

How do you solve quadratic problems on numbers, consecutive integers and reciprocals?

Write consecutive integers as xx and x+1x + 1 and a reciprocal as 1x\frac{1}{x}, then form and solve the equation.

Worked example 1.
The product of two consecutive positive integers is 132132.

x(x+1)=132x2+x−132=0(x+12)(x−11)=0x(x + 1) = 132 \qquad x^2 + x - 132 = 0 \qquad (x + 12)(x - 11) = 0

x=−12x = -12 is rejected because the integers are positive. The integers are 1111 and 1212.

Worked example 2. A number plus its reciprocal is 103\dfrac{10}{3}.

x+1x=1033x2−10x+3=0(3x−1)(x−3)=0x=3 or 13x + \frac{1}{x} = \frac{10}{3} \qquad 3x^2 - 10x + 3 = 0 \qquad (3x - 1)(x - 3) = 0 \qquad x = 3 \text{ or } \frac{1}{3}

Both roots are valid here.

An everyday example. A book lies open, and the product of the two facing page numbers is 420420. Then x(x+1)=420x(x + 1) = 420 gives x=20x = 20: pages 2020 and 2121.

The substance. Reject a root only when the problem rules it out — sometimes both answers are correct.

How do you solve quadratic problems on ages and on two-digit numbers?

Write future ages as x+nx + n, and a two-digit number with digits xx and yy as 10x+y10x + y.

Worked example 1 — ages.
A mother is 2626 years older than her daughter. In 33 years, the product of their ages will be 360360.

(x+3)(x+29)=360x2+32x−273=0(x + 3)(x + 29) = 360 \qquad x^2 + 32x - 273 = 0
x=−32+1024+10922=−32+462=7x = \frac{-32 + \sqrt{1024 + 1092}}{2} = \frac{-32 + 46}{2} = 7

The negative root is rejected. The daughter is 77 and the mother 3333; check 10×36=36010 \times 36 = 360.

Worked example 2 — two-digit number. A two-digit number is 44 times the sum of its digits and 22 times the product of its digits.

10x+y=4(x+y)⇒y=2x10x+y=2xy⇒12x=4x210x + y = 4(x + y) \Rightarrow y = 2x \qquad 10x + y = 2xy \Rightarrow 12x = 4x^2

x=0x = 0 is rejected, since a tens digit cannot be zero, so x=3x = 3, y=6y = 6 and the number is 3636.

An everyday example. Family age puzzles at a birthday party often hide exactly this kind of quadratic.

The substance. Always check the final answer in the original words, not just in the equation.

How do you solve quadratic problems on speed, time, distance and streams?

Use time == distance ÷\div speed to write each time in terms of xx, set up the stated difference or total, and remember that upstream speed is the boat's speed minus the stream's speed while downstream speed is their sum.

Worked example 1 — train.
A train covers 480480 km. If its speed were 88 km/h more, it would take 33 hours less.

480x−480x+8=33840=3x(x+8)x2+8x−1280=0(x+40)(x−32)=0\frac{480}{x} - \frac{480}{x + 8} = 3 \qquad 3840 = 3x(x + 8) \qquad x^2 + 8x - 1280 = 0 \qquad (x + 40)(x - 32) = 0

Speed =32= 32 km/h (a speed cannot be negative). Check: 48032=15\frac{480}{32} = 15 h and 48040=12\frac{480}{40} = 12 h.

Worked example 2 — stream. A boat's speed in still water is 1515 km/h. It goes 3030 km upstream and returns in 4.54.5 hours. Find the speed of the stream xx.

3015−x+3015+x=4.5900=4.5(225−x2)x2=25\frac{30}{15 - x} + \frac{30}{15 + x} = 4.5 \qquad 900 = 4.5(225 - x^2) \qquad x^2 = 25

Stream speed =5= 5 km/h. Check: 3010+3020=3+1.5=4.5\frac{30}{10} + \frac{30}{20} = 3 + 1.5 = 4.5 h.

An everyday example. A river ferry takes longer against the current than with it.

The boundary case. The stream speed must be less than 1515 km/h, otherwise the boat could never move upstream.

How do you solve area, perimeter and work problems and reject the inadmissible root?

Form the equation from area formulas or work done per hour, solve, and reject impossible roots with a reason.

Worked example 1 — field. A rectangular field has perimeter 7070 m and area 300 m2300\text{ m}^2.

x(35−x)=300x2−35x+300=0(x−15)(x−20)=0x(35 - x) = 300 \qquad x^2 - 35x + 300 = 0 \qquad (x - 15)(x - 20) = 0

The sides are 2020 m and 1515 m.

Worked example 2 — path.
A park 6060 m by 4040 m has a path of uniform width inside along its edges. The remaining lawn has area 1500 m21500\text{ m}^2.

(60−2x)(40−2x)=15004x2−200x+900=0x2−50x+225=0(x−5)(x−45)=0(60 - 2x)(40 - 2x) = 1500 \qquad 4x^2 - 200x + 900 = 0 \qquad x^2 - 50x + 225 = 0 \qquad (x - 5)(x - 45) = 0

x=45x = 45 is rejected, because 40−9040 - 90 would make the lawn's width negative. The path is 55 m wide.

Worked example 3 — pipes. One pipe fills a tank in 55 hours more than another. Together they fill it in 66 hours.

1x+1x+5=1612x+30=x2+5xx2−7x−30=0(x−10)(x+3)=0\frac{1}{x} + \frac{1}{x + 5} = \frac{1}{6} \qquad 12x + 30 = x^2 + 5x \qquad x^2 - 7x - 30 = 0 \qquad (x - 10)(x + 3) = 0

The pipes take 1010 and 1515 hours; x=−3x = -3 is rejected as time cannot be negative.

An everyday example. Two taps filling an overhead water tank on a roof follow the same work equation.

The substance. The reason for rejection carries marks — write it, do not just cross the root out.
Exam tip

What earns full marks on quadratic word problems?

Define xx in words, form the equation clearly, and finish with a sentence answer that states which root was rejected and why.

-
Begin with let xx be the quantity asked for
-
Write every other quantity
in terms of xx
- Solve fully, then test both roots against the situation
- State the reason for rejecting a root
- Give units in the final answer

The trap. Rejecting a root automatically. In the reciprocal problem, both 33 and 13\frac{1}{3} are correct.
Did you know

What does the rejected root in the park problem actually describe?

In the park problem, x=45x = 45 was rejected. Yet it does satisfy the equation.

Substitute it: (60−90)(40−90)=(−30)(−50)=1500(60 - 90)(40 - 90) = (-30)(-50) = 1500. Two negative lengths multiply to give a positive area, so the algebra is perfectly happy.

The equation only knows that a product equals 15001500; it does not know that lengths must be positive. That extra knowledge comes from you — which is exactly why checking roots against the real situation matters.
Exam relevance

How do quadratic word problems prepare you for JEE Main and NEET Physics?

This is foundation work for Class 11 Complex Numbers and Quadratic Equations in JEE Main and Class 11 Motion in a Straight Line, part of both JEE Main and NEET Physics.

What gets built on. In kinematics, s=ut+12at2s = ut + \frac{1}{2}at^2 is a quadratic in tt. Its two roots often mean the object passes the same point twice — going up and coming down — while a negative root is rejected as a time before the motion began.

Question types. Numericals where choosing the correct root is the whole point of the question.

The trap that costs marks. Rejecting a physically meaningful second root, such as the time at which a ball returns to the same height.
Key takeaways

What must you be able to do from this part?

- Four steps: let xx, form, solve, check and reject
- Consecutive integers xx and x+1x + 1: product 132132 gives 1111 and 1212
- Reciprocal: x+1x=103x + \frac{1}{x} = \frac{10}{3} gives 33 and 13\frac{1}{3}, both valid
- Ages: daughter 77, mother 3333; two-digit number 3636
- Speed: time == distance ÷\div speed; train speed 3232 km/h; stream speed 55 km/h
- Area: path width 55 m, rejecting 4545 m
- Work: pipes take 1010 and 1515 hours
- Always give the reason for rejecting a root

Make up your own two-pipe tank problem with different times and see whether your equation leads back to the numbers you chose.

Ready to put this into practice?

Create a personalized quiz on this exact topic — free to start.

Create your own quiz on Solving Problems Based on Quadratic EquationsCreate a free account
← Back to all articles